Jandy's Meanderings: Jandy’s Meanderings » American Idol Top 10 Girls
Debbie
· 2 years ago
My comment to John during tonight's show, to save the non-power house voices..."start singing country"...then they would be set apart with a different segment of people voting for them-Haley or Alaina could do it;)what do you think?And no, Alaina singing Dixie Chicks doesn't count;(
I did not realize that Stephanie is only 19! WOW! I think I might root for her. I don't know yet. I don't care for Melinda...I wish Simon would quit saying the same thing about her. The judges must really, really like her, because they never pick on her song choice or fashion choice(which would have been fair) like they do others. They always seem very gentle and careful with her. Hmmmm
I agree with you about Sabrina. There is a glitch in her likability factor.
I agree with your going home picks...the ones that make it through better bring out the country!
Jandy
· 2 years ago
Singing country is actually a really good idea! Right now they're all singing variations on Motown/R&B;/Diva songs. Gina might be able to get away with moving toward rock (and away from powerhouse-diva songs), but rock chicks tend to fail quickly, so maybe she's right not to do that.
Yeah, that's true. Stephanie is younger than she seems (not meaning that to be a value judgment, either way). I do like her, she just doesn't WOW me. Well, Melinda has impressed me from her first audition, and singing Aretha Franklin and Frank Sinatra songs well generally gets on my good side quickly. ;) I agree with you, though, that Simon needs to quit with the "everyone else has an ego, you don't blah blah blah" line. He's run that into the ground, however true it is.
mark
· 2 years ago
I'm glad you're enjoying the show, but why haven't you blogged about VM lately?
Jandy
· 2 years ago
Mark - because I'm behind. My cable provider decided to suddenly stop carrying the CW, so I've had to start downloading the episodes again, and I tend to get behind when I do that. I believe I'm three episodes behind right now.
I think the last episode I watched was the one where the one girl was given RU-486. I know there was some huge kerfluffle in the fandom after last week's episode, but I have no idea what happened, or why everyone was upset about it, so please don't tell me. I'll get caught up next week probably, after I finish a paper for next Wednesday.
All Comments
I did not realize that Stephanie is only 19! WOW! I think I might root for her. I don't know yet. I don't care for Melinda...I wish Simon would quit saying the same thing about her. The judges must really, really like her, because they never pick on her song choice or fashion choice(which would have been fair) like they do others. They always seem very gentle and careful with her. Hmmmm
I agree with you about Sabrina. There is a glitch in her likability factor.
I agree with your going home picks...the ones that make it through better bring out the country!
Yeah, that's true. Stephanie is younger than she seems (not meaning that to be a value judgment, either way). I do like her, she just doesn't WOW me. Well, Melinda has impressed me from her first audition, and singing Aretha Franklin and Frank Sinatra songs well generally gets on my good side quickly. ;) I agree with you, though, that Simon needs to quit with the "everyone else has an ego, you don't blah blah blah" line. He's run that into the ground, however true it is.
I think the last episode I watched was the one where the one girl was given RU-486. I know there was some huge kerfluffle in the fandom after last week's episode, but I have no idea what happened, or why everyone was upset about it, so please don't tell me. I'll get caught up next week probably, after I finish a paper for next Wednesday.